Is Regifting Rude? The Rules for Doing It Right
Almost everyone has a drawer of gifts they'll never use: a candle in a scent they don't like, a book they already own, a gadget that duplicates one they have. Letting them gather dust helps nobody. Giving them to someone who would actually love them can be the most sensible, least wasteful thing to do.
The problem isn't regifting. It's careless regifting. This guide covers the five rules that keep it kind, what you should never pass on, and exactly what to say if you're ever found out.
The five-question regifting test
Before you pass anything on, it needs a yes to all five of these.
1. Is it brand new? Unopened, unused and ideally still in its original packaging. A candle that’s been lit once, a book with a cracked spine or a scarf that’s been worn is no longer a gift. It’s a hand-me-down.
2. Would this person actually want it? Regifting works when the gift suits the new person better than it suited you. If you’re only trying to get rid of it, they’ll feel that. The question is “who would love this?”, not “who can I give this to?”
3. Is the new person outside the original giver’s circle? Don’t give your sister-in-law’s gift to someone else in the same family, or a coworker’s gift to another coworker. Different friend group, different office, different town is the safe rule.
4. Is it free of anything personal? Nothing handmade, monogrammed, engraved or chosen with a special meaning. Those gifts carry the giver’s effort and love, and passing them on is the one form of regifting most people find hurtful.
5. Is every trace of the first gift gone? Check inside the box, inside book covers and under the tissue for old tags, cards, gift receipts and inscriptions. More regifters are caught by a forgotten card than by anything else.
What you can regift
- Unopened toiletries and bath sets, within their expiry date.
- Books you already own a copy of, in new condition.
- Duplicate kitchen gadgets and homeware, still boxed.
- Candles and diffusers, unlit and in their wrapping.
- Gift cards, with the full balance and an expiry date checked.
- Wine and spirits, unopened, if you know the recipient drinks.
- Games and puzzles, still sealed.
What you should never regift
- Handmade or personalised items, such as knitted scarves, engraved jewellery or a painting.
- Heirlooms or family pieces. These belong in the family, even if they’re not to your taste.
- Anything used, opened or tested. This includes perfume that’s been sprayed “just once”.
- Food near its best-before date. Check chocolates, cookies and hampers carefully.
- Samples and branded freebies. A conference tote or a free-with-purchase makeup bag looks exactly like what it is.
- Signed books or anything with a dedication.
- Things the original giver will see. A painting on your friend’s wall that came from your aunt is a problem at every family party.
Where regifting works best
White elephant swaps. In a white elephant game, nobody’s buying for anyone in particular, so a good new item from your regift drawer fits well, as long as it’s worth about the same as the price limit. It often counts at its usual retail value. For what tends to get stolen, see our white elephant gift ideas.
Charity drives and raffles. Toy drives, school tombolas and community raffles welcome unused gifts, and nobody minds where they came from.
Close friends who’ll appreciate the honesty. “My work gave me this, and I know you love this brand” can be more personal than a gift you bought at the last minute.
Keep a regift drawer, and a note
If you regift often, keep unwanted gifts together in one place, with a sticky note on each saying who gave it and when. That single habit prevents almost every awkward moment. Before you pass anything on, check the note and make sure the new person and the original giver don’t know each other. A drawer like this also saves you when someone gives you a gift and you didn’t get them one, as long as you give it later with a card rather than on the spot.
Should you say it’s a regift?
The Emily Post Institute’s advice on regifting is that the most straightforward way to regift is to say so. Honesty often makes the gift more personal: “I was given two of these, and you’re the first person I thought of.”
If you’d rather not say, the same advice sets a high bar: the gift must be in its original packaging with all its parts, it must not be handmade or personalised, and you must be sure neither person would be offended if they found out. Re-wrap it and write a new card. And never invent a story about how you chose it specially. If they ask where it’s from, tell the truth.
What to say if you’re caught
It happens. The best answer is short and honest:
“You’re right, it was a gift. It wasn’t quite me, and I knew you’d love it more. I hope that’s OK.”
Don’t apologise at length or make excuses. Most people are more amused than offended, especially if the gift really does suit them.
If regifting doesn’t feel right
- Return or exchange it, if you have a gift receipt.
- Sell it and put the money toward a gift you choose yourself.
- Donate it to a charity shop, a shelter or a toy drive.
- Swap it at a gift swap party with friends, where everyone brings their unwanted gifts.
Regifting on a budget, done well
Regifting isn’t a way to avoid thinking about a gift. It’s a way to put a good thing in the right hands. If you want a gift that shows real thought for very little money, our cheap but thoughtful gifts and gifts for friends under $20 guides are full of ideas. And if the honest answer is that they’d rather have money, read our guide to whether cash is a rude gift.
Frequently asked questions
Is it rude to regift a present?
Not if it's new and unused, it suits the new recipient, and it goes outside the original giver's circle. It becomes rude when the gift is used, handmade, personalised, or likely to be recognised by the person who gave it to you.
Should you tell someone a gift is regifted?
Saying so is the simplest and most honest option, and it often makes the gift feel more personal: 'I was given this, and it's so much more you than me.' If you don't mention it, make sure nobody would be hurt if they found out, and never claim you chose it specially.
Is it OK to regift a gift card?
Yes, as long as the balance is complete and you've checked the expiry date and any fees. Gift cards are among the easiest things to regift, because they're always new.
What should you never regift?
Handmade or personalised items, anything used or opened, gifts with sentimental or family meaning, expired food or beauty products, free samples and branded freebies, and anything the original giver might see.