Gift Exchange

12 Last-Minute Secret Santa Gifts You Can Buy Today

Our top picks

  1. Most usefulSimple Modern insulated tumbler$18–$25Check price
  2. Easiest to findYankee Candle Balsam & Cedar (medium jar)$18–$25Check price

We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How we make money. Prices are typical ranges and change often, so check the retailer for today's price.

It's the morning of the exchange, or the night before, and you still have nothing. Maybe you forgot, maybe your parcel is stuck somewhere in the post, or maybe you drew a name late. Whatever happened, you don't need a miracle. You need one good gift from a shop you can reach today.

Every pick below is something big stores usually stock in December: Target, Walmart, CVS, Walgreens or a supermarket. Most come in under $25, which fits most Secret Santa limits. If you have a week rather than an hour, our main Secret Santa gift ideas are matched to personality and worth the extra time.

Under $25

Ferrero Rocher gift box (24 pieces)

$12–$18

Every drugstore and supermarket stocks Ferrero Rocher in December, often near the checkout, so this is the safest gift you can grab in five minutes. The gold-wrapped hazelnut chocolates come in a clear box that already looks like a present. Nearly everyone likes them, and they're easy to share at a desk or at home.

Best for
Anyone you know little about, especially at work.
Check price

Royal Dansk Danish butter cookies tin

$5–$10

The blue tin is a holiday classic, it's on the shelf at almost every grocery store and pharmacy, and it costs far less than your limit. That leaves room to pair it with a nice mug or a bag of good coffee from the same shop. Together they make a small coffee-break set that looks put together on purpose.

Best for
A $10 to $20 exchange, or as the base of a two-item gift.
Check price

Potted rosemary 'Christmas tree'

$10–$18

In December, many supermarkets and Trader Joe's sell rosemary plants trimmed into a small cone shape, like a tabletop Christmas tree. It's festive, it smells wonderful when you brush it, and they can cook with it afterwards. It looks considered even though it took two minutes to pick up, and it costs less than most cut flowers.

Best for
Home cooks and people with a sunny windowsill.
Check price

Amaryllis bulb kit

$12–$25

Amaryllis kits come with a bulb, a pot and soil, and they appear in garden centres, supermarkets and big-box stores every winter. The fun is that it's a gift that keeps going: it grows quickly, and a huge red or white flower opens a few weeks later, just when January feels grey. It needs almost no skill.

Best for
Anyone who'd enjoy watching something grow, including older colleagues.
Check price

Codenames card game

$15–$20

Codenames is a word-guessing party game for two teams, and it's in the game aisle at Target, Walmart and most bookstores. Rules take two minutes to explain, any number of people can play, and it works for families, friends and office parties. It's a gift they can open and play on the same day.

Best for
People who host, have kids at home or love game nights.
Check price

LEGO Creator 3-in-1 small set

$10–$20

The small Creator 3-in-1 sets build three different models from the same bricks, such as an animal, a vehicle or a little house. Every toy aisle has them. Adults like them as a calm 20-minute desk build, and they work just as well if your recipient passes it on to a child. The box looks like a proper present.

Best for
LEGO fans, desk-toy people and anyone with kids at home.
Check price

Buffalo Games 500-piece jigsaw puzzle

$10–$15

Puzzles are a quiet holiday ritual for a lot of people, and 500 pieces is the right size: finished in an evening or two, not a month. Buffalo Games puzzles are on the shelf at Target, Walmart and many drugstores, with scenes from cosy cabins to cats. Pick an image that fits something you know about them.

Best for
Introverts, puzzle families and older colleagues.
Check price

Muk Luks cabin socks

$10–$18

Warm, thick socks are one of the few clothing gifts that fit almost everyone. Muk Luks cabin and slipper socks are sold at Walmart, Target and department stores, often as a boxed gift set in December. They feel like a small luxury in a cold house, and a boxed pair looks much more giftable than a loose pack.

Best for
People who are always cold or work from home.
Check price

Sol de Janeiro body mist (travel size)

$20–$25

Sol de Janeiro's body mists are a hit with younger coworkers and friends, and the warm, sweet scents are easy to like. Target, Ulta and Sephora carry the small travel bottles, which fit a $25 limit and look like a treat they wouldn't buy for themselves. Most stores also sell holiday sets at this price.

Best for
Beauty lovers in their teens, 20s and 30s.
Check price

Movie theatre gift card with theatre candy

$20–$25

Supermarket and drugstore gift-card racks usually carry AMC, Regal or Cinemark cards. Load one for about $20 and tape it to a box of theatre candy from the same shop, and it becomes a night out rather than an envelope. It's a good choice when you know nothing about their tastes, because they pick the film.

Best for
Film fans, couples and anyone near a cinema.
Check price

Simple Modern insulated tumbler

$18–$25

A good insulated tumbler gets used every day, and Simple Modern's are sold at Target and Walmart in plenty of colours. They keep coffee hot through a long meeting and water cold in the car. It's practical without being boring, and it costs much less than the better-known brands that tend to sell out in December.

Best for
Commuters, gym-goers and anyone always carrying a drink.
Check price

Yankee Candle Balsam & Cedar (medium jar)

$18–$25

Balsam & Cedar smells like a fresh Christmas tree without being sweet, which makes it one of the safest candle scents for someone you don't know well. Yankee Candle jars are stocked at Target, Walmart and many supermarkets. A medium jar burns for weeks and fits most Secret Santa budgets with room to spare.

Best for
Anyone who keeps a candle on the go at home.
Check price

Forgot your gift? A 30-minute plan

  1. Tell the organiser privately. A quick “I’m running late with mine, it’ll be there” stops them worrying and keeps your recipient from feeling left out. Our office Secret Santa etiquette guide covers what to say at work.
  2. Check stock before you drive. Search the store’s app for the item, then choose in-store pickup. Most big chains hold pickup orders within a couple of hours.
  3. Buy one thing and buy it well. A single good item looks more deliberate than three random small ones.
  4. Write a real tag. “To Sam, from your Secret Santa” plus one line about why you chose it. That line is what makes a quick gift feel personal.
  5. Wrap it simply. A gift bag and tissue from the same store take one minute and look tidy.

If your gift won’t arrive in time

Ordered online and it’s stuck? Don’t turn up empty-handed. Print a picture of the gift, or a screenshot of the order with the price hidden, and put it in a card that says it’s on its way. Your recipient still gets a reveal, and the real gift follows. Remote groups often run into this, which is why our guide to how to do Secret Santa online sets a shipping deadline. Before you order anything else this month, check this year’s Christmas shipping deadlines.

Where to shop when you’re out of time

Store What to grab
Drugstore (CVS, Walgreens) Chocolate boxes, cookie tins, candles, gift-card rack
Supermarket Rosemary trees, amaryllis kits, flowers, chocolates, gift cards
Target or Walmart Games, LEGO, puzzles, tumblers, socks, beauty sets
Bookstore Games, puzzles, and a paperback they’ll actually read

When the limit is $10

A tight limit makes last-minute shopping easier, not harder. A Royal Dansk tin, a small LEGO set or a 500-piece puzzle all fit. For more ideas at that price, see our gifts under $10. If it’s a white elephant rather than a Secret Santa, the rules are different: the gift needs to appeal to everyone, so see our last-minute white elephant gifts instead.

For other ways to run a holiday swap next year, with less of a scramble, start with our main gift exchange ideas.

Frequently asked questions

What can I get for Secret Santa at the last minute?

Something a big store has in stock today: a box of good chocolates, a cookie tin, a potted rosemary tree, a card game like Codenames, a small LEGO set, cosy socks, a candle or a movie gift card with candy. Add a handwritten tag so it looks planned.

What do I do if I forgot my Secret Santa gift?

Tell the organiser privately, then buy something today and hand it over as soon as you can, even a day late. A late gift with an honest note is far better than none. If you can't shop, give an e-gift card with a printed card on the day.

Is a gift card OK for Secret Santa?

Yes, especially at work. Make it feel less last-minute by choosing a place they'd enjoy, such as their local cinema or coffee shop, and pair it with something small to unwrap.

What if my Secret Santa gift won't arrive in time?

Print a photo of the gift or the order, put it in a card with a note saying it's on its way, and give that on the day. It still feels like a reveal, and the real gift follows.

Gift Exchange

17 Gift Exchange Ideas People Actually Want (Under $25 & $50)

The best gift exchange gifts are useful, a little fun, and right for almost anyone. Under $25, a Contigo leak-proof travel mug, a sherpa throw or a fast card game like Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza. Under $50, an Owala FreeSip bottle, Ticket to Ride or a Graza olive oil set. Land near the price limit and avoid sizes, strong scents and niche hobbies.

17 ideas
Gift Exchange

14 Secret Santa Gift Ideas Under $20 (That Feel Personal)

Great secret Santa gifts under $20 match one thing you've noticed about the person: Jade Leaf matcha for the matcha drinker, Nielsen-Massey vanilla for the baker, a Kong toy for the dog owner, a Pop Mart blind box for the collector, or a Love Letter card game for the one who's always up for a game. Five minutes of detective work beats a bigger budget.

14 ideas
Gift Exchange

10 Last-Minute White Elephant Gifts That Still Get Stolen

The best last-minute white elephant gifts are things everyone at the party would use: a gas or restaurant gift card hidden in a box, a K-Cup variety pack, a Frito-Lay snack box, Jenga, a three-flavour popcorn tin, a faux-fur throw, a power bank or scratch-off tickets. You can find all of them at a supermarket, drugstore, Target or Walmart on the day.

10 ideas
Budget Gifts

14 Gifts Under $10 That Don't Look Cheap

The best gifts under $10 are small upgrades to things people use every day, from brands they recognise: Lindt Lindor truffles, a Burt's Bees lip balm set, Pilot G2 pens, a Scrub Daddy, HotHands warmers, a Nite Ize Gear Tie or a pack of UNO. Pair two of them, or add a handwritten note, and a $10 gift feels considered rather than cheap.

14 ideas