Gift Exchange

10 Last-Minute White Elephant Gifts That Still Get Stolen

Our top picks

  1. Most stolenGas or restaurant gift card, hidden in a big box$20–$25Check price

We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How we make money. Prices are typical ranges and change often, so check the retailer for today's price.

A white elephant gift doesn't need to be clever. It needs to be something most people in the room would happily take home, because anyone could end up with it. That's good news when you're shopping on the way to the party: useful, shareable and slightly indulgent beats a gag gift you panic-bought at the checkout.

Everything below is usually stocked at a supermarket, drugstore, gas station, Target or Walmart in December. When you have more time, our full list of white elephant gift ideas has the gifts that get fought over every year.

Under $25

Gas or restaurant gift card, hidden in a big box

$20–$25

Gift cards get stolen more than almost anything else in a white elephant, because everyone drives or eats out. The supermarket gift-card rack has gas, chain restaurant and pizza cards. The trick is the wrapping: tape the card inside a cereal box or a big shoebox with some weight in it, so nobody can guess it from the shape.

Best for
Office parties and mixed groups where tastes vary.
Check price

Green Mountain K-Cup variety pack

$15–$25

Most homes and offices have a pod coffee machine, so a big K-Cup variety box is something lots of people in the room can use. Supermarkets and Target sell 24 to 40-pod packs with several roasts. It's a practical gift that looks generous because of the size of the box, and it disappears quickly in an office kitchen.

Best for
Office swaps and coffee-drinking crowds.
Check price

Frito-Lay classic mix variety pack

$15–$22

A big box of 30 to 40 single-serve bags of Doritos, Cheetos, Lay's and Fritos is one of those gifts people laugh at when they open it, then steal two turns later. It's easy to find at Walmart, Target and warehouse clubs. It's perfect for families with kids, and great for anyone who packs a lunch.

Best for
Families, teens and anyone with a snack drawer.
Check price

Jenga Classic

$12–$18

Jenga is in every toy aisle and many drugstores, and it can be played at the party itself, which makes it more fun to win than a gift that sits in a bag. Everyone knows the rules, kids and adults both like it, and it's a nice thing to bring out at family gatherings over the rest of the holidays.

Best for
Family parties and groups with kids.
Check price

Three-flavour popcorn tin

$15–$25

The big tins with butter, cheese and caramel popcorn turn up in supermarkets, drugstores and warehouse clubs every December. They're big, festive, easy to share at the party, and the tin gets reused for years. It's a crowd-pleaser that nobody minds ending up with.

Best for
Big mixed groups and family parties.
Check price

10,000mAh portable power bank

$15–$25

A pocket-size power bank is the kind of practical gift people don't buy for themselves until their phone dies at an airport. Target, Walmart and Best Buy carry them in the electronics aisle, and many drugstores have them near the phone cables. Choose one with both USB-C and USB-A ports so it works with any phone.

Best for
Commuters, travellers and teens.
Check price

Bluetooth beanie

$15–$25

A knitted hat with flat headphones built in sounds like a novelty, but people who walk the dog or commute in the cold love it. They usually sit in the winter accessories or electronics section at Walmart and Target. It gets a laugh when it's opened and a steal once someone tries it on.

Best for
Cold-climate groups, dog walkers and runners.
Check price

A bottle of wine or bourbon with a bow

$15–$25

In an adult group, a decent bottle is one of the gifts most likely to be stolen right before the game ends. Most supermarkets sell it, and a bow plus a gift bag is all the wrapping you need. Choose a crowd-friendly red or a well-known bourbon rather than something unusual.

Best for
Adult friend groups and neighbourhood parties.
Check price

Scratch-off lottery tickets

$10–$25

A small stack of scratch-offs from any gas station or supermarket is a white elephant tradition. Everyone wants to know if it's a winner, which makes it the most dramatic gift to open. Some groups agree that whoever ends with the tickets scratches them on the spot. It's cheap, quick to buy and fun to watch.

Best for
Casual adult parties that like a bit of drama.
Check price

$25 to $50

Faux-fur throw blanket

$20–$30

Soft throws are among the most fought-over white elephant gifts, and Target and Walmart stock plenty in the home aisle in December. A faux-fur or sherpa throw in a neutral colour feels like a treat, suits anyone's sofa and looks great as it comes out of the box. Choose one with a ribbon so it's ready to give.

Best for
Almost any group, especially in a cold climate.
Check price

What makes a rushed gift still get stolen

Three things decide whether a white elephant gift gets fought over or left on the table, and none of them need extra time:

  • Most of the room can use it. Coffee, snacks, warmth and gift cards cross every age and taste. A very personal gift goes home with someone who doesn’t want it.
  • It’s close to the limit. Under-spending shows. If the limit is $25, a $20 gift in a big box beats a $10 gift in a small one.
  • It’s fun to open. Weight and size build suspense. Put small gifts inside a bigger box before you wrap.

What to skip when you’re shopping in a hurry

Checkout-aisle novelties, candles with strong scents, clothing in a specific size and anything that needs batteries you didn’t buy. They’re the gifts left in the last pile. Gag gifts can work, but they need more thought than a quick shop allows. If you want something funny, see our funny white elephant gifts when you have time to order.

Where to shop on the way to the party

Store Best grabs
Gas station Gas gift cards, scratch-offs, snacks
Supermarket Popcorn tins, coffee pods, wine, gift-card rack
Drugstore Chocolates, power banks, gift cards
Target or Walmart Throws, games, snack boxes, tech accessories

Running the game too?

If you’re also the host, set the rules before the first gift is opened: how many steals per turn, when a gift freezes, and whether the first player gets a final swap. Our white elephant rules explain each one, and the free white elephant game tracker keeps count of turns and steals on your phone. Buying for a named person rather than a pile? See our last-minute Secret Santa gifts instead. For more party formats, our main gift exchange ideas guide covers the rest.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good last-minute white elephant gift?

Something most people at the party would use: a gas or restaurant gift card hidden in a box, a K-Cup variety pack, a big snack box, a popcorn tin, a cosy throw, a power bank or Jenga. You can find all of them at a supermarket, drugstore, Target or Walmart.

Can you give a gift card for white elephant?

Yes, unless the host has banned them. Gift cards are among the most stolen gifts. Hide one in a heavier box so nobody can guess it from the shape.

What can I buy at a grocery store for white elephant?

A three-flavour popcorn tin, a K-Cup variety pack, a big box of chocolates, a bottle of wine for an adult group, or a gas or restaurant gift card from the gift-card rack.

How much should a last-minute white elephant gift cost?

Stay at the group's limit, usually $20 to $30. A gift well under the limit is the one nobody steals, so spend close to it.

Gift Exchange

17 Gift Exchange Ideas People Actually Want (Under $25 & $50)

The best gift exchange gifts are useful, a little fun, and right for almost anyone. Under $25, a Contigo leak-proof travel mug, a sherpa throw or a fast card game like Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza. Under $50, an Owala FreeSip bottle, Ticket to Ride or a Graza olive oil set. Land near the price limit and avoid sizes, strong scents and niche hobbies.

17 ideas
Gift Exchange

14 White Elephant Gift Ideas That Get Stolen Every Time

The white elephant gifts that get stolen are useful things with some wow: a Stanley Quencher, a heated throw, a LEGO Botanicals set or a Squishmallow. Funny gifts work too, but only if they're also usable, like a burrito blanket, a Dash mini waffle maker or an Otamatone. Pure joke gifts are the ones left behind at the end of the night.

14 ideas
Gift Exchange

14 Funny White Elephant Gifts People Actually Fight Over

The funny white elephant gifts that get stolen are jokes that are also useful: a Squatty Potty, an IllumiBowl toilet night light, dinosaur taco holders, a 5 lb gummy bear or The Comfy wearable blanket. Pure novelty gifts like a Nicolas Cage sequin pillow or a giant pizza pool float in December get the biggest laugh on opening. Keep it office-safe unless you know the room, and stay close to the price limit.

14 ideas
Gift Exchange

White Elephant Rules: How to Play, Steal Limits and Variations

Everyone brings one wrapped gift and draws a number. On your turn you either unwrap a gift from the pile or steal one that's already been opened. If your gift is stolen, you choose again straight away. A gift freezes after three steals, and player 1 gets one last chance to swap at the end. Our free white elephant game tracker keeps count of turns and steals on your phone.

6 min read